Diaz v. Local No.241
- William Pauley
- 1:17-cv-08898
- U.S. District Court · Southern District of New York
- 1
In Diaz v. Local No. 241, Judge Pauley dismissed plaintiffs’ claims without prejudice for lack of standing and closed the case.
The seven plaintiffs—Anicasia Diaz, Ludwig Alonso, Julia DeLeon, Maria Gomez, Fredeswinda Morciglio, Mariola Truszkowski, and Pedro Quinones—and the defendants Local No. 241, Transport Workers Union of America, University Division, and Columbia University in the City of New York.
What happened
In Diaz v. Local No. 241, the court entered judgment dismissing the plaintiffs’ claims against Local No. 241, Transport Workers Union of America, and Columbia University in the City of New York. The judgment states that the dismissal followed the reasons given in a March 19, 2021 memorandum and order.
The court dismissed the claims because the plaintiffs lacked standing, meaning they were not legally entitled to bring those claims in court. The judgment states that the dismissal was without prejudice because standing is a jurisdictional issue, and it closed the case.
Judge William Pauley’s ruling therefore ended this case without barring the plaintiffs from bringing the claims again. The judgment was entered on April 20, 2021.
The detailed version
- Diaz v. Local No.241 · No. 1:17-cv-08898
- William Pauley
- Apr. 20, 2021
Ruling
The judgment states that the plaintiffs’ claims against Local No. 241, Transport Workers Union of America, University Division, and Columbia University in the City of New York were dismissed for lack of standing. Standing is a jurisdictional requirement concerning whether a plaintiff may ask a federal court to decide a claim.
Disposition
Because the court treated standing as jurisdictional, it dismissed the claims without prejudice. The judgment also states that the case was closed. It identifies the reasons for the ruling as those stated in the court’s March 19, 2021 Memorandum and Order, which is not included in the provided text.
Read the full 1-page opinion on CourtListener, the free public archive maintained by the Free Law Project.