Court, Explained
U.S. Federal District Courts
←Back to docket
S.D.N.Y.Procedural orderFiled Mar. 11, 2024

Lugo v. The Center

Judge
Garnett
Docket
1:21-cv-07423
Court
U.S. District Court · Southern District of New York
Pages
2
Civil ProcedurePro SeMotion to Dismiss
In one sentence

In Lugo v. Lesbian & Gay Communities Service Centers, Judge Garnett ordered service on Forrest Solutions, terminated Chris LaPlant, and required a service affidavit.

Who this affects

Carlos Lugo, who was representing himself; Forrest Solutions, which the court directed the Marshals Service to serve; Chris LaPlant, whom the Clerk was directed to terminate as a party; and Lesbian & Gay Communities Service Centers, which was ordered to file proof of service for its motion to dismiss.

What happened

In Carlos Lugo v. Lesbian & Gay Communities Service Centers, et al., the case was reassigned to Judge Margaret M. Garnett. Lugo had filed an amended complaint adding Forrest Solutions and asked the court to arrange service through the U.S. Marshals Service.

The court directed the Clerk to issue an amended summons and prepare the paperwork needed to serve Forrest Solutions. Because Lugo had permission to proceed without prepaying fees, the court extended the service deadline to 120 days after the summonses are issued. The court also directed the Clerk to terminate Chris LaPlant as a party because the claims against LaPlant had already been dismissed with prejudice in an earlier order.

Judge Garnett also ordered Lesbian & Gay Communities Service Centers to file proof that it had served its motion to dismiss the amended complaint within seven days. After that filing, the court said it would set a schedule for briefing on the motion. The order was mailed to Lugo, who was representing himself.

The detailed version

For law students, journalists, and other readers who want the full reasoning

Case
Lugo v. The Center · No. 1:21-cv-07423
Judge
Garnett
Date
Mar. 11, 2024

Background

The case was reassigned to Judge Margaret M. Garnett, who stated that all prior orders, dates, and deadlines would remain in effect unless the court ordered otherwise. On January 17, 2024, Carlos Lugo filed an amended complaint adding Forrest Solutions as a defendant. On February 7, 2024, Lugo asked the court to direct the U.S. Marshals Service to serve Forrest Solutions and supplied an address for service.

Service on Forrest Solutions

The court directed the Clerk of Court to issue an amended summons for Forrest Solutions and to prepare and send the necessary paperwork to the U.S. Marshals Service. Lugo had been granted permission to proceed without prepaying fees, so he was entitled to rely on the court and the Marshals Service to serve the defendant. The court extended the time for service to 120 days after the summonses are issued. If service is not completed within that period, the opinion states that Lugo should request an extension of time.

Chris LaPlant

The court stated that Judge Broderick’s October 12, 2023 Opinion and Order had dismissed Lugo’s claims against Chris LaPlant with prejudice. Because the amended complaint asserted the same claims against LaPlant, the Clerk was directed to terminate LaPlant as a party in this action. This order relied on the earlier dismissal and did not separately analyze the underlying claims.

Motion to dismiss

The court ordered Lesbian & Gay Communities Service Centers to file an affidavit of service for its motion to dismiss the amended complaint within seven days. The court stated that, after the affidavit was filed, it would set a briefing schedule for the motion. The opinion does not decide that motion.

Disposition

This was a procedural order concerning reassignment, service, termination of a previously dismissed party, and scheduling. The Clerk was directed to mail the order to Lugo, who was proceeding without a lawyer.

The authoritative version

Read the full 2-page opinion on CourtListener, the free public archive maintained by the Free Law Project.

Open opinion PDF →
Summary written with AI assistance. See how summaries are made. Spot something wrong? Tell us.